Story IV - Reflections

(Author's Note: In this Mansfield Park variation, Sir Thomas Bertram looks back on his life.)

Mansfield Park, October 1808

Sir Thomas Bertram sat behind the ornate desk in his beloved study, listening to his namesake and heir give his report on the family plantations on Antigua. Tom Bertram's face bore the tanned skin common among those who had been to the West Indies.

"So," the tall young man of twenty-five said, "the situation was not as bad as we feared. Once I replaced the overseer and brought in a new man, one who would actually feed the workers, all problems seemed to be solved." He sat down, an unreadable expression on his face.

Sir Thomas leaned forward. "You've done well, Tom. I doubt if I could have done better. No, you have done exactly what I would have done, had I gone with you. I am proud of you." Tom waved off the praise. "What ails you, Son?"

"Father," he hesitated and then looked hard at the older man, "must we own slaves?"

The question surprised Sir Thomas. "How else can we manage our plantations? Who will harvest the sugar cane?"

"You were not there. I must say it turned my stomach to see how the men were treated. Whipped, starved-"

"Surely not on our lands?"

"No, not after I replaced the overseer. But our neighbors are not so humane. The women - some were for the use of the owners. It…it troubles me, Father. As honest Christians, can we not pay the workers?"

Sir Thomas bit back his rejoinder, for he could see that this was a serious question. "I have been to Antigua, and I will admit I do not like it either. I do not like it at all. But, if we free our slaves and pay them, our costs go up. Who will buy our sugar when the others can undercut our price? How will the workers or their families get food then? That is assuming, of course, the other landowners will let us free our slaves. There is nothing we can do. It is the way things are done there. We must treat our people better than the others."

"Father, I am sorry to disagree with you, but I am of the opinion that owning other men is evil. No amount of money can justify it. If we cannot change things there, should we be in Antigua at all?"

"You are saying I should sell our plantations?"

Tom looked down. "If it were up to me, yes, I would sell."

Sir Thomas could see that his son's whole heart was in this. Tom has changed. He is a man, now, and I must treat his advice as I would that from any other man.

"You have given me much to think about. What you ask for is no small thing. I promise I will give it my full consideration."

"I know you will, Father. I am sorry to trouble you about this."

"Say nothing of that." He rose from his chair. "I raised you to learn this business, to be prepared to be the master of Mansfield. I will not begrudge you your honest opinions." He crossed in front of the desk and embraced Tom. "I say again, I am exceedingly proud of you."

Tom smiled, but there was the ghost of pain in his eyes, pain Sir Thomas had seen before. It haunts him still.

"Thank you, Father. I should go to my mother, now. It is almost tea, and Fanny can use the rest. Will you join us?"

Sir Thomas glanced at his desk. "No, I have a few other letters to write. Make my excuses, and I shall see you at dinner." Tom took his leave and left the room, Sir Thomas' eyes following him out.

Tom had not always been the hard-working, dependable man he was now. His university years were ones of drinking and carousing. Debts from gambling, especially at the horse track, had hurt the family finances terribly. It reached a crescendo at about the time of his Uncle Norris's death, and instead of having a friend hold the Mansfield living until Edmund was ready for it, Sir Thomas was forced to make a different arrangement, and Dr. Grant was now the rector.

"I blush for you, Tom," Sir Thomas had berated him then, in his most dignified manner. "You have robbed Edmund for ten, twenty, thirty years, perhaps for life, of more than half the income which ought to be his. It may hereafter be in my power, or in yours-I hope it will-to procure him better preferment. But it must not be forgotten that no benefit of that sort would have been beyond his natural claims on us, and that nothing can, in fact, be an equivalent for the certain advantage which he is now obliged to forego through the urgency of your debts."

The effect of his words had been immediate. The pain of guilt had driven Tom to mend his ways and be useful to his family. Edmund had forgiven him - Edmund would forgive anyone, thought Sir Thomas - but Tom had not forgotten. Sir Thomas was happy and feared for his eldest. Guilt can gnaw away at a man's soul just as well as hard living.

"Father?" Sir Thomas glanced up to see his eldest daughter, Maria, peeking in the room. "Are you not joining us for tea?"

"No, my dear. As you see, I still have much work to do."

"Oh," she said as she walked in, dark and lovely, in full bloom at twenty-one. "Have you a moment?"

"Of course, my dear." He indicated a chair and sat next to her. "What is it?"

"I do not believe I thanked you, as I should, for your assistance with the matter over Mr. Rushworth."

Sir Thomas said nothing, only nodded thoughtfully.

"You were right. I do not believe we were well-suited. I…I did not feel for him as I ought."

Sir Thomas watched with kindly eyes. No, my dear. You, and your Aunt Norris, only saw Sotherton Court and a house in Town and twelve thousand a year. I am glad you see clearly now. I cannot say the same for your aunt.

"I only hope his disappointment is of short duration," she added.

"I pray that be the case. To be fair, you offered him little encouragement."

Maria hung her head. "I should have offered him none as Fanny advised."

Sir Thomas patted her hand. "There, there. I shall tell you that my interview with Mr. Rushworth, while uncomfortable, was not devastating. Whatever pain he is feeling will be soon overcome with other thoughts."

A small smile appeared at Maria's lips. "Perhaps there will be new statuary at Sotherton?"

Sir Thomas should have scolded her for her impertinence, but said instead, "I should not be surprised. Now, dear, surely this melancholy stems from another source?"

Maria sighed and turned her head to the windows. "Father, was it necessary for Mr. Crawford to be sent away?"

Sir Thomas took a deep breath, thankful again for Fanny's intelligence. "I am afraid so, dear. Mr. Crawford is a very charming man with much to recommend him. A good estate and a good income. Excellent conversation. He can easily make any girl fall in love with him. But to attempt to charm all three of my girls, all at the same time? It shows a want of propriety, even a deficiency of morals. It certainly is a danger to sisterly affection."

Maria blushed. Sir Thomas saw it as a reminder of the rows she had had with Julia and even Fanny. "It…it is just that he was the most agreeable man I have ever met."

"I know. How did the Bard put it? 'One may smile and smile, and be a villain.'"

"I do not believe him as bad as that!"

"Perhaps. Perhaps it is the fact that my girls are so lovely, he could not make up his mind."

Maria blushed again, this time pleased. He took her hand.

"Please try not to let this matter trouble you. We shall go to Town for the Season. There will be balls and parties and proper gentlemen aplenty for all my girls!"

It served, and a small smile graced Maria's pretty lips. She was a child born for the hustle and bustle of London, Bath and the society of the ton. "As long as they are agreeable!"

With mock seriousness Sir Thomas said, "They will be, or your brothers will run them off!" Maria laughed. "Now, dear, off you go to tea, while I finish my correspondence before dinner."

Maria jumped to her feet. "Oh, Father! How thoughtless of me to prattle on when you have business to conduct."

"None of that! Have I not told you my door is open to you at all times?" He gave her a small hug. "Nothing is more important to me than you and your sisters and your brothers."

"Thank you," she said as she gave him a peck on his cheek, and then she went away.

Sir Thomas stood in the middle of the room, thinking over the conversation and recalling the twin disasters he had avoided. His thoughts came back to the reason he had been able to protect his family.

Fanny.

He recalled the conversation he had with Lady Bertram and Mrs. Norris eight years ago in his wife's parlor. Lady Bertram had suggested bringing her sister Price's eldest daughter to Mansfield to give relief to the Price family, already with nine children.

He had hesitated, for the responsibility was great, and to some sanctimonious words from Mrs. Norris, he had said, "There will be some difficulty in our way, Mrs. Norris, as to the distinction proper to be made between the girls as they grow up. How to preserve in the minds of my daughters the consciousness of what they are, without making them think too lowly of their cousin. And how, without depressing her spirits too far, to make her remember that she is not a Miss Bertram. I should wish to see them very good friends, and would, on no account, authorize in my girls the smallest degree of arrogance towards their relation; but still they cannot be equals. Their rank, fortune, rights, and expectations will always be different. It is a point of great delicacy, and you must assist us in our endeavors to choose exactly the right line of conduct."

Sir Thomas grimaced in pain. How could he say such words about anyone, but especially about his beloved Fanny?

But he was not the man then that he was now. He had affection for his wife, Maria, Lady Bertram, and he dearly loved his children, Tom, Edmund, Maria, and Julia. He was also a man of great responsibilities, a baronet and MP with land in Northampton and Antigua. His task had been to care for their properties and interests, while it fell to Lady Bertram to raise the children.

Unfortunately, Lady Bertram proved to be a neglectful mother. In the years after Julia's birth, she had become lethargic and withdrawn, interested only in her comfort and her pug dogs. It was left to Miss Lee, the governess, to raise the children with the guidance of Mrs. Norris. When nine-year-old Fanny came to Mansfield in the summer of 1801, Sir Thomas had little to do with her.

How all that changed on Easter of 1803! Sir Thomas had always considered himself liberal and generous, and when he learned that Fanny did not ride, he provided her with a horse. To his surprise, she was very reluctant to learn. At first, he thought it might be stubbornness or stupidity, but after a word with Edmund, he approached the girl.

"Fanny," he had asked, "do you not wish to learn to ride?"

"Oh, yes, sir. It is just that…that they are so big!"

"Are you frightened, child?"

Fanny looked down, obviously ashamed. "Yes, sir."

"Fanny, we will stop this foolishness. The horse is very gentle, and you will learn to ride. Do we understand each other?"

Her lip quivered. "Yes, sir."

Sir Thomas would never know what possessed him to say the next words. "And I will teach you."

The girl looked up in wonder and apprehension, and Sir Thomas' heart was struck. Why, the girl is frightened of me! He smiled a kind smile and said, "Come, my dear. Change into your habit, and we will have our first lesson."

Dutifully, Fanny showed up at the appointed place in full riding habit. Now aware of the child's fears, Sir Thomas gently introduced her to the horse. After spending no little time becoming acquainted, Sir Thomas carefully lifted the girl onto the beast's back. In soothing tones for both the horse's sensibilities as well as for hers, he instructed Fanny about the basic skills of riding. Slowly, both horse and rider relaxed, and as they moved about the paddock at a leisurely pace, Sir Thomas saw Fanny's spirits rise. Lesson over for the day, he reached up to bring the girl down from the saddle. To his surprise, Fanny threw her arms about his neck and hugged him tightly.

"Oh! Oh, Uncle!" she cried. "Thank you, thank you so much!" He could feel her tears of joy on his neck. Touched beyond belief, he found himself hugging the child to his chest.

"Shall…shall we…" Fanny's voice died out.

"What is it, child?"

"Shall we do it again tomorrow?"

Such a simple request! How could he refuse? "Of course we shall, Fanny." He impulsively kissed her cheek, which resulted in a renewal of her loving hug.

Sir Thomas felt a tear of remembrance run down his check. He could not know at the time how his world had changed that day. Mrs. Norris had learned of the riding lesson and, in her usual unpleasant manner, congratulated Sir Thomas on his unnecessary condescension for his unworthy niece. His response was to have Maria and Julia ride along with him and Fanny on the morrow, for he had begun to see the evil of treating Fanny differently from her cousins.

The next day, the five of them set off - for Edmund had joined them - on a short tour of the estate. Sir Thomas reveled in having the attention of the children. How pleasant it was! When Maria complained of the pace, Sir Thomas gently reprimanded her, pointing out that Fanny was just beginning to learn. Maria started to make a comment about Fanny's stupidity, and her father lost his temper.

"Maria! How dare you speak so of your cousin! Do you think you were such an accomplished rider when you first learned? I want to hear your complete apology to Fanny - quick now!"

The young people were shocked at the outburst. While they all respected - and not a little feared - Sir Thomas, it was rare that he raised his voice, and he had never before done so to his daughters. Maria mumbled the required words to Fanny, and Sir Thomas had to be satisfied with it. A worrisome thought had entered his mind. My sister-in-law has surely spoiled my daughters. This needs to be corrected as soon as may be, for Maria will be out soon and hopeless of remedy.

"Maria, Julia, Edmund, I wish to make something clear. Fanny is not only your cousin, but she lives here. She has left her family to join ours. As she is part of our family, I expect her to be treated as such. There will no more such talk. I will not tolerate it."

From that moment, Sir Thomas began to take an intense interest in the children. When he discovered that Mrs. Norris had left instructions that Fanny's little sitting room be left with no fire in the grate, he made sure that the room was warm at all times. A talk to Miss Lee ensured that Fanny would receive no less instruction than the other girls would, and he made clear to his daughters that he expected them to show greater kindness to their poor cousin.

Fanny was not the only recipient of his attention. As Tom was already away at school, Sir Thomas would ride and shoot with Edmund constantly. He took great interest in his daughters' accomplishments, praised them when deserved, and kindly encouraged their improvement if necessary.

More importantly, he worked hard to gain the children's trust. He encouraged them to come to him whenever they desired, to talk of things, to show off their triumphs, or to have a kindly ear hear their troubles. The last was the hardest to achieve, but by his constancy, he won them over.

Many would wonder if this did not take him away from his duties. If fact, Sir Thomas briefly wondered if there were enough hours in the day to do everything that needed to be done. Yet, he found that by entrusting his steward with the day-to-day details of running the estate and making fewer speeches on the floor of the House of Commons, his world did not come crashing down around his ears, and his days were, for the most part, far more enjoyable.

When Mrs. Norris protested, seeing her territory being usurped, Sir Thomas had been quick to put her in her place.

"Not see my children? What nonsense is this? Who should be the children's confidant if not their father?"

"Well, sir, that is very kind of you - indeed, very liberal - but you have many duties, besides, and there are others who have less demands upon them. Surely, this burden can be lifted from your shoulders. Ah, I see you agree with me! Leave everything to me, sir, and-"

"Mrs. Norris, I beg to differ! I most certainly do NOT agree with you. These are my children, I shall do as I wish, and I will thank you not to interfere!"

She cowered. "Oh, sir, I would not think of it! You misunderstand me, Sir Thomas. I only wish for your peace of mind. I shall carry news of your condescension to dear Edmund, Maria, and Julia - depend upon it!"

"That will not be necessary. The children already know of my wishes. Your services are not required, for not only would they be repetitious, they would be incomplete."

"Incomplete, sir?"

"Indeed. Have you forgotten Fanny?"

"Fanny! Certainly, you do not mean Fanny! You cannot mean Fanny!"

"I most certainly do, madam."

"But, she is not your daughter!"

"You are correct. But MY NIECE is under my protection. I remind you that you are not my wife and can have no power here. Be good enough NEVER to correct me again."

As the years flowed by, Sir Thomas saw, to his intense pleasure, that his daughters took pains to befriend and finally love their cousin. The benefits to all were apparent. Maria and Julia grew less self-adsorbed while Fanny became more lively. More often than not, Sir Thomas would observe the three of them walking the grounds of Mansfield, arms linked, thick as thieves, and laughing over secrets. Most importantly, Fanny's innate strong moral foundation was not weakened by the constant presence of her two cousins. No - rather, it was they who were reminded to do good so as not to shame themselves before their younger friend.

Sir Thomas could not think when the sea change happened-when Fanny stopped being his niece and the children's cousin and became daughter and sister. It came about so slowly and consistently that it was engrained in their minds before they realized it. Of course, Mrs. Norris was outraged over the change, and in the aftermath of her husband's death in 1806, tried to reassert herself. But it was too late - the damage had been done. The girls would give up Aunt Norris's spoiling in favor of Fanny's agreeable company.

With Miss Lee leaving that same year, Sir Thomas resolved to spend even more time with his children, especially with the return of the now-contrite Tom. Tom threw himself into the study of estate management with the same enthusiasm he had once shown for far more idle pastimes. By the spring of '07, there was such an improvement in Tom that it was decided, reluctantly on Sir Thomas's part, that Tom should sail to the West Indies to inspect the family's properties and report back to his father. At the time, the baronet had been concerned, but as it turned out, it was a very good thing he remained at Mansfield, for in the winter of 1808, Mr. Rushworth came to court Maria, and in the spring the Crawfords arrived.

The Crawfords! Sir Thomas still shuddered at the thought of those two. Relations of the Grants, who had been established at Mansfield Parsonage, the brother and sister had constant access to the estate. Edmund was immediately smitten by the sister, Mary Crawford, and Sir Thomas could not fault him for it. Beautiful, witty, clever, talented, and with a good fortune, Miss Crawford was a good match for Edmund. She befriended all the Bertram girls and Fanny too.

But - there was a worldliness, an unconscious cruelty in her manner that occasionally seemed to make itself apparent. Only a word or two, and then she was extremely agreeable again. Edmund was mostly blind to it, but Sir Thomas and Fanny saw it.

One other observation troubled Sir Thomas. Edmund had been, by education and personality, destined for the church. Thornton Lacey was his once he took his vows. However, on more than one occasion, Miss Crawford spoke of the church as being a waste of Edmund's talents. She seemed bent on persuading him to forgo preaching and go into the law or some other fashionable occupation. Sir Thomas did not interfere, for he was determined that Edmund should live his own life.

At first appearance, Henry Crawford was also a very agreeable guest. Sir Thomas could see that Maria liked him better than Mr. Rushworth. This was not a concern, for while the newcomer's fortune was less, it was not lacking, and he made up for his relative want of money with an overabundance of wit and charm, something Mr. Rushworth was sorely lacking.

But as the weeks went by, it was apparent that Crawford was flirting with Julia, as well. When Fanny reported the same behavior towards herself, Sir Thomas knew he had to act. It was at that moment that Mr. Rushworth chose to declare himself. It was a busy day indeed for the baronet, as he had to disappoint one suitor and banish another.

It was a shame, he thought. Crawford had some of the makings of a good man. He might have been happy to part with any of his girls into his hands, but his indiscriminate attentions to all three at once showed there was something amiss with the man. No fortune was enough for Sir Thomas to entrust the happiness of Maria, Julia, or Fanny to such a rake.

Crawford's departure led to another. Miss Crawford asked for forgiveness for her brother. When that was refused, she begged and then insisted on pardon for her wayward relation. An astonished Edmund was witness to it, and his amazement doubled when the lady demanded that he choose between her and his family. His refusal led to an irrevocable breach. The Crawfords departed from Mansfield directly, leaving in their wake mortified relations, two disappointed ladies, and one broken-hearted gentleman.

Edmund had yet to recover, Sir Thomas knew, although he rallied upon his brother's return from Antigua. He spent most of his time otherwise preparing to take orders and walking the grounds with Fanny. An afternoon in her company seemed to improve his spirits, Sir Thomas noticed.

A movement in the gardens caught Sir Thomas's attention. Sure enough, there were Edmund and Fanny walking about the roses, probably discussing scripture. Sir Thomas smiled at the sight, a plan that had begun to germinate a few weeks ago developing strong roots.

It had been some time since Sir Thomas had considered Fanny as his youngest daughter. Over the years he had toyed with the idea of making that position official - of adopting the girl. It was done all the time. No one would remark about it, save Mrs. Norris.

But now, Sir Thomas was glad he had not acted on his thoughts. For a better way now lay before him. Would not Fanny be even more delightful as a daughter-in-law? He had suspected for some time that Edmund was the girl's most particular friend and cousin. How deep did that admiration go? Did she love him? Could she love him enough to marry? In temperament and talents she was perfect for Edmund.

What were Edmund's thoughts on the matter? Knowing his son, he had probably never given it any passing consideration. Yet, it was Fanny's company he sought. It was always Fanny's opinions he valued. It would not take much to turn such naked respect and admiration into something deeper, the baronet thought.

Time, Sir Thomas smiled. All it takes is time. Let Edmund go take orders and return. Fanny will be waiting for him. Then everything will run its natural course. But a new pretty dress for dear Fanny would not be out of place for Edmund's welcome home party, would it?

No, it would not.

The End


© 2009 Jack Caldwell

Previous Story

Variations Index

Next Story